The offspring tokens felt kind of random to me and the fish tokens, while funny, felt needlessly large and would have been happier with them metal to reduce on the plastics. Otherwise, I personally enjoy it. My wife who I got it for, surprisingly doesnt like it as much. For the noted reasons above, ahe would rate it a 3. She felt the fish tokens ans dice as plastic were unfortunate
While Beadle & Grimm's always does amazing work, this one really blew me away. The faux leather box by itself is incredibly cool (as is all the stuff inside it) but the quality of the minis and maps is exceptional.